Case Study

IMD Professor Reacts: Mike Wade says EU vs. Google is misguided and politically motivated

"... the only engines I know anything about are search..."

 

 

Photo: Fotolia

by Michael Wade

The European Parliament recently passed a non-binding vote urging anti-trust regulators to break up Google’s various businesses. Europe has had Google in its sights since 2010 and the tech giant has had to deal with privacy issues, the erasing of “right to be forgotten” search results and other controversies on the continent.

The recent attempts by the EU Parliament to censure and control Google’s activities are misguided and possibly politically motivated.

Google is successful largely because it offers a good product for free. The vast majority of people use the Google search engine by choice and find the results to be helpful. Users are not forced to use Google search in a monopolistic manner. They have the choice to use other free-of-charge competing services like Bing or Yahoo.

Competitors exist, but they are simply not as good as Google, which has an estimated 90% internet search market share in Europe.

The EU’s suggestions to force ‘neutral search’ results – an attempt to stop Google from manipulating the results to its advantage – are completely misguided. Google uses an algorithm to predict the most relevant results. Of course this is biased – towards Google’s interpretation of the most relevant results. But the vast majority of users agree with what a Google search presents. And at any rate what would a neutral search yield? Random results? It is difficult to see how this could be at all helpful to internet users.

Advertisers are also free to use competing services, although Google does have a huge market share in advertising. However, Google’s prices are not unreasonable. Its largest revenue source – adwords – is based on a series of auctions. Google does not set fixed prices. Demand and supply determine the prices paid. When it comes to Google’s second largest revenue source – Adsense – the company gives back a healthy 70% of all revenue to clients.

From a business perspective, Google is in trouble in the long term due to its high reliance on clicks to advertisers’ websites. No clicks mean no revenue, and people are clicking ads less often. Google knows it needs to innovate to survive. Governments should be encouraging companies like Google to innovate, not trying to stifle them.

Apple is a much more dangerous potential monopolist. Google’s Android is open but Apple’s iOS isn’t. Apple’s ecosystem is largely closed and tightly controlled.

All in all, the action against Google seems not to be coming from the grass roots of the EU population, but from legislators wishing to protect local interests and score points by bashing an easy target.

Read More…

Michael Wade is Professor of Innovation and Strategic Information Management at IMD. His interests lie at the intersection of strategy, innovation, and information management. He is co-director of the Orchestrating Winning Performance (OWP) program and teaches in Leading the Global Supply Chain (LGSC) and the Breakthrough Program for Senior Executives (BPSE).

Advertisements

About Zoran Opalic

Professional in design and publishing industry. Conceptualize and orchestrate designs and redesigns that effectively reinforce and build brand images. Proven ability to drive record-high campaign in increasing publication sales and execute successful product launches...

Discussion

No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Aston Martin DB10

Production will be strictly limited to 10 of the bespoke sports cars, developed and built by the designers, engineers and highly skilled craftspeople at Aston Martin’s Gaydon headquarters.

Architect Oscar Niemeyer

"My work is not about form follows function, but form follows beauty or, even better, form follows feminine."

BACK to BASICS: Portraits

Portraits of people are one of the first elements of the photography used in newspapers.

Typography: x-heigh

In typography, x-heigh refers to the heigh of lower case letters without upper or lower parts when compared to capital letters...

Designer George Lois

“I always knew I was the most talented kid in the school, ” says George Lois of his time at Music and Art. “I was lucky to be exposed to the city’s best art education"...

BODY COPY

Newspaper typefaces require a higher legibility then typefaces used for other printed products. Newspaper are printed on a paper of lesser quality under high speed.

How to redesign 1

Good redesign is driven by a deep understanding of the editorial mission of the publication.

Headline on photographs

The eternal dilemma! Dilemma of all editors on the planet Earth – to put or not put the headline or any kind of type in the photo.

Design Facts

Three elements that will greatly help you to understand how readers are observing you.

Typeface: NY Times Magazine

Sunday Magazine is an expansive family of fonts for information in tiny spaces and headlines at large sizes.

Infographics

When, why and whether to use infographic. The basic fact is that infographic refresh the publication, and it contributes to originality of your product.

A well-designed publication

Everything that a well-designed publication must have...

Archives

Categories

%d bloggers like this: